by Dennis Wagner
The Arizona Republic
02 November 2009
WINDOW ROCK - A green controversy fueled by
coal-fired power plants is raging on America's largest Indian
reservation.
On one side is Joe Shirley Jr., president of
the Navajo Nation, who rejects the notion of climate change even
though he recently won an international award for
environmentalism. On the other are environmentalists opposed to
power plants in Indian Country and to the coal mines that provide
their fuel. Caught in the middle are tribal members concerned with
economic survival and the protection of sacred lands.
The dispute centers on fundamental questions of
religion and heritage, as well as tribal finances.
The Navajo Generating Station near Page, which
uses coal from mines on Black Mesa, employs hundreds of tribal
members and helps finance the tribal government. The Desert Rock
Energy Project, proposed in western New Mexico, has been under
consideration for years. The $3 billion plant would be fueled by
coal from a new mine, bringing more jobs and revenue to the
Navajos.
The Environmental Protection Agency wants the
Navajo Generating Station to install costly air-scrubbing
equipment, an expense the tribe and some Arizona utility companies
say could lead to the plant's closure. Environmental groups, which
have targeted the plant for years because of the emissions-related
haze that builds up over the Grand Canyon, applaud the scrubbers.
Andy Bessler, Sierra Club regional
representative in the Southwest, said coal-fired power plants
account for about 30 to 40 percent of carbon emissions worldwide.
The Navajo Generating Station, the nation's third-largest emitter
of nitrogen oxides, spews 19.9 million tons of carbon emissions
each year and uses 9.1 billion gallons of water - enough to fill
Saguaro Lake twice with water left over. The nearby Four Corners
Power Plant is the second-largest emitter of nitrogen oxides.
"If we want to take care of global warming,
coal power plants are the low-hanging fruit," Bessler said. "We
can't just continue with business as usual if we want to protect
the planet."
But Shirley, who last week was suspended by the
tribal council amid an unrelated Navajo power struggle, challenges
the very theory of worldwide climate change.
"There's no signs that have told me it's a
problem," he said. "There's a lot of people running around out
there saying, 'The sky is going to fall down. It's going to be the
end of the world.' I don't believe that. I don't know what global
warming is about. . . . Maybe I'm blind, I don't know. Maybe I
don't have the intelligence. But where are the signs?"
Shirley, whose father-in-law is a medicine man,
acknowledged that some Navajo traditionalists recognize climate
change as a threat and have joined tribal conservation groups such
as Diné CARE in claiming he sold out Native heritage to big
business. Those critics, he said, have been sucked in by
environmentalist propaganda.
Last month, Shirley criticized the Sierra Club,
Grand Canyon Trust and other green organizations for interfering
with Navajo sovereignty and caring more about insects or fish than
the lives of Native Americans. The rebuke was especially stunning
from the leader of a tribe that has for years aligned itself with
green groups in political causes.
Six months ago, Shirley accepted the
Nuclear-Free Future Award in Norway for collaborating with
environmental groups to fight uranium mines near the Grand Canyon.
Shirley, a Christian, said he consulted with Navajo
traditionalists before deciding that carbon-spewing power plants
and open-pit coal mines do not damage the Earth.
But Tony Skrelunas, a Navajo who works as
Native American program coordinator for the Grand Canyon Trust,
expressed dismay that Shirley spoke of resources without
emphasizing stewardship.
"Even sheep herders learn to protect land from
overgrazing," he said, "and to do the right thing so rains will
come. . . . The thing that I find shocking is that, as Navajos, we
are taught that there are different monsters in creation that try
to destroy us. I think one of those that is really rising up is
climate change."
More than 1,500 United Nations climate
scientists agree that Earth's temperature has begun to rise at a
potentially disastrous rate, and that carbon emissions are the
major cause. Skrelunas noted a study issued this spring by Jayne
Belnap, a scientist with the U.S. Geological Survey, which says
global warming is expected to increase temperatures in the Four
Corners area 10 degrees by 2100. Already, Belnap reports, drought
has tripled the number of dust storms swirling from the high
desert into the Colorado Rockies.
"I grew up on Big Mountain. We raised sheep,"
said Skrelunas. "It's massively different now. . . . Not as green.
It doesn't rain anymore. There are lots of dust storms."
The Navajo reservation sprawls over portions of
Arizona, New Mexico and Utah, with an estimated population over
250,000.
Anna Frazier, coordinator for Diné CARE, said
the mines and electric plants have wrecked the land, sucked
springs dry and polluted skies. She said Shirley ignores those
facts, trading heritage for short-term cash.
"He's ignoring the fundamental laws of the
Navajo people," Frazier said. "Our traditions tell us we have to
protect and preserve all living things."
Shirley said his priority is to help the Navajo
people, who suffer from an unemployment rate over 50 percent, with
average annual incomes under $15,000.
Environmentalists have exacerbated the
financial woes, he added, forcing the closure of a tribal sawmill
and helping to shut down another power plant - the Mohave
Generating Station near Laughlin, Nev. - that received coal from
Black Mesa.
"They came onto our land," Shirley said. "They
didn't tell me, 'Here, Mr. President. Here are other green jobs.'
They just shut us down, put more people into impoverishment. You
want me to accept that?
"I'm working on independence, period," he said.
"If it takes green jobs to get us back to standing on our own two
feet, I'm for green jobs. If it takes Desert Rock or Navajo
Generating Station . . . I'm for Desert Rock and Navajo Generating
Station."